From our Holdings (30/09/2026)
The Ritual Murder Accusation and Its Role in Franco’s Intended Re-Catholicization of Spain
Vicente Sánchez-Biosca
The cover of the May 1934 special edition of the National Socialist magazine Der Stürmer featured a cartoon by Philipp Rupprecht (Fips) depicting the medieval antisemitic trope of ritual murder. Several Christians, apparently children, are bleeding out streams of black blood that one of their two “Jewish” killers is collecting on a tray decorated with a Star of David, while the other wields a blood-stained knife. With their hooked noses and grim expressions, the grotesquely deformed murderers evoke a monstrous iconography. The grisly bloodshed wrought by the executioners and the angelic posture of the victims allude not only to murder, but also to the use of blood for sinister rites. The caption implies that the “diabolic Jews” have been shedding human blood for ritual reasons throughout the millennia and calls on the German people to “strike back” and get rid of them.[1] The dichotomization, radicalism and consequence of Fips’s cartoon are characteristic of the vitriolic imagery consolidated under the Nazi regime.
Yet illustrations of the ritual murder legend, which is of longue durée and has been reactivated time and again since the Middle Ages,[2] did not always reach such heights of monstrosity and have been employed with somewhat different intentions in other contexts. Published nine years later, the official Spanish schoolbook for history Yo soy español (I am Spanish) contains another example of this motif, which, according to Hannah R. Johnson, “bears all the hallmarks of a limit event – indeterminacy, powerful emotional and political investments.”[3] Chapter 18 of the heavily illustrated and widely disseminated first-grade textbook, whose target audience was schoolchildren aged six, bears the title Los judíos matan a un niño (The Jews kill a child) and refers to the alleged ritual murder of Dominguito del Val, a seven-year-old Christian boy supposedly killed by Jews under orders of the chief rabbi in the city of Zaragoza in 1250 and celebrated as a martyr by the Catholic Church.
What is striking is that this book was published in the period immediately after the Spanish Civil War (1936-1939), when, under the aegis of National Catholicism, the Franco regime took on the mission of “re-Catholicizing Spain” to defend it against the supposed threat of modernity.[4] Written by the education inspector and elementary school teacher Agustín Serrano de Haro and approved by both the Church and the State, Yo soy español contained “warnings to educators” of the need to instill patriotic love for Spain in their charges.[5] The book combines accounts of Spain’s “national glories” (the Crusades, the Conquest of the Americas, Spanish unification and the expulsion of the Moors and Jews in 1492, Franco’s victory in the Spanish Civil War in 1939) with central elements of religious doctrine. It also sought to highlight the enemies of both Christianity and “Spanishness.”
The inclusion of the legend of Dominguito del Val, which “has been the subject of many works of art and literature” since the 16th century and “enjoyed a revival in its prominence during the late nineteenth and early twentieth century,” is highly significant in this regard.[6] It focuses on the Jews’ supposed hatred for Christians due to their love for Jesus and the Virgin Mary, which is described as the Jews’ sole reason for killing the boy. Dominguito himself is characterized as a downright saint: charitable, courageous and devout, he refuses the Jews’ demand to step on his cross, whereupon “they crucify him like they crucified Christ.”[7] The story thus synthesizes two basic tropes of medieval Christian anti-Judaism: the accusations of ritual murder and deicide, with Jews considered collectively guilty for the killing of Jesus Christ.[8]
ALAVA – TU Berlin, inventory number 11077
The illustration by José López Arjona, another elementary teacher, visualizes these tropes while adding some others. Four grim-faced adult “Jews” dressed in tunics are nailing a child to a wall and collecting his blood in cups, a detail that is omitted in the text.[9] The drawing is inspired by an iconography of “Jews” that was widespread in antisemitic Europe at that time (devious, dirty, with exaggerated facial features). However, it is impossible to ignore the orientalist iconography of the four “Jews”: Their beards, turbans and robes give them a strong resemblance to Arab stereotypes. This is hardly surprising, given that “orientalism has always been not only about the Muslims but also about the Jews.”[10] This orientalism inspired by classical pictorial stereotypes reveals a peculiarity about Spanish antisemitism in the Franco era. As a result of the expulsion of the Jews from the country in the late 15th century, it was not associated with a propaganda policy targeting a sector of the population but with a narratively and iconographically constructed ideological fantasy.
As the historian François Soyer suggests, “The portrayal of Jews in orientalised, ‘Moorish’ attire fitted nicely in the historical narrative espoused by nationalist and conservative Catholic Spaniards in which Jews, like Muslims, were presented as an alien, foreign ‘other’ with no claim to ‘Spanishness’ or ‘Hispanicity’ (Hispanidad).”[11] Indeed, Spanish national identity is constructed in stark opposition to the Jews in this chapter of Yo soy español and López Arjona’s drawing: Dominguito is conceived of visually as the counterfigure to “the Jew.” Inspired by crucifixion iconography of the Baroque tradition, his body alludes to the “human” vulnerability of the dying Christ. Instead of pain, his facial features express a beatific innocence that makes him seem—despite his crown of thorns and his look of supplication—to have already attained sainthood.
Yo soy español continued to form part of the school curriculum for many years in Francoist Spain. It would not be until the first edition published after the Church’s rapprochement with the Jewish people that the episode would be removed from the text altogether: The Nostra Aetate declaration, promulgated by Pope Paul VI on October 28, 1965, called for the elimination of anti-Jewish elements in Catholic teaching and rejected the notion of Jewish deicide. This condemnation of antisemitism seems to be the main reason for the revision of Yo soy español. However, Jews would continue to be described in Franco’s speeches as part of “the Judeo-Masonic conspiracy.” Moreover, the alleged ritual murder of Dominguito del Val has since been re-featured in new publications produced within the Church, and Dominguito was venerated as a child martyr in the Catholic archdiocese of Zaragoza up until 2017.[14]
[1] Cf. Der Stürmer, Sondernummer 1, May 1934, p. 1, ALAVA – TU Berlin, inventory number 07650.
[2] Cf. Rainer Erb, “Die Ritualmordlegende: Von den Anfängen bis ins 20. Jahrhundert,” in: Susanna Buttaroni/Stanislaw Musial (eds.), Ritualmord. Legenden in der europäischen Geschichte, Wien 2003, pp. 11-20, here p. 12.
[3] Hannah R. Johnson, Blood Libel. The Ritual Murder Accusation at the Limit of Jewish History, Ann Arbor 2012, p. 167.
[4] See, by way of example, Giuliana di Febo, Ritos de Guerra y de Victoria en la España franquista, Valencia 2012. For the role played by schoolbooks in socializing both the iconography and narrative of the new state, see Lara Campos Pérez, Los relatos de la nación. Iconografía de la idea de España en los manuals escolares (1931-1983), Madrid 2010.
[5] Agustín Serrano de Haro, Yo soy español. El libro de primer grado de historia, Madrid 1943, p. 5, ALAVA – TU Berlin, inventory number 11077.
[6] François Soyer, “The Blood Libel in Illustrated Books and Comics for Children in Twentieth-Century Spain,” in: Cadernos de Estudos Sefarditas 22 (2020), pp. 11-53, here p. 19 and 30.
[7] Serrano de Haro, Yo soy español, p. 56.
[8] Cf. Matthias Blum, “Gottesmord,” in: Handbuch des Antisemitismus. Judenfeindschaft in Geschichte und Gegenwart. Bd. 3: Begriffe, Theorien, Ideologien, published by Wolfgang Benz, Berlin 2010, pp. 113-115.
[9] While some versions of the legend of San Dominguito del Val include the ritual use of the boy’s blood as medicine or to make bread for Passover, this aspect is not featured in the heavily abridged text of Yo soy español. Cf. for instance Dionisio Cabezas, La flor del Ebro. San Dominguito del Val, Barcelona 1907, ALAVA – TU Berlin, inventory number 11074.
[10] Ivan Davidson Kalmar/Derek J. Penslar, “Orientalism and the Jews: An Introduction,” in: Ivan Davidson Kalmar/Derek J. Penslar (eds.), Orientalism and the Jews, Waltham, Massachusetts 2005, pp. xiii-xl, here p. xiii.
[11] Soyer, “The Blood Libel,” p. 27.
[12] Cf. Serrano de Haro, Yo soy español, p. 56.
[13] Soyer, “The Blood Libel,” p. 17.
[14] Cf. ibid., p. 12 and 32 f.